Read

Search form

The Choice In Portland: Austerity Versus a People's Budget

The Choice In Portland: Austerity Versus a People's Budget
Mon, 3/4/2013 - by Mark Vorpahl

It's no secret that most cities, counties, states and school districts in the U.S. are facing big deficits. What is less understood is the extent to which austerity cuts have become politicians' bi-partisan response to the situation. The dramatic measures being implemented in Portland, Oregon are no exception.

By "austerity" is meant a bag of policies intent on "reforming," that is, reducing spending by cutting jobs and public services, tearing up social contracts that workers have benefited from, and, in general, making workers and the poor do all the sacrificing to close budgetary imbalances. These austerity measures range from potential cuts to Social Security and Medicare to cuts on a local level that go after our schools, social services, parks, and infrastructure.

While this "sacrificing" is imposed on the vast majority of citizens, obscenely low tax rates for big business and the wealthy are being left in place as their profits swell and their dominance over the political system increases. To appreciate the scope of this trend, one need merely note this New York Times Op-Ed, which pointed out that there are "nearly $1.1 trillion in annual deductions, credits and other tax breaks that flow disproportionately to the highest income Americans and that cost more, each year, than Medicare and Medicaid combined."

The Case in Portland

Portland's newly elected Democratic Mayor Charlie Hales has announced that there is a $25-to-$40 million hole in the city's budget. In response, he is demanding that all 27 city bureaus submit budget proposals with 10 percent cuts. This latest round follows several consecutive years of budget cuts.

The cuts already put into effect have resulted in lost jobs, underfunded services and a decline in Portland's livability. While it is not clear yet how Hales will wield his cleaver, he is signaling that his cuts will be the deepest yet. The programs that he has already targeted - at-risk teen summer internships, job-training efforts and youth bus passes, among others - will have an immediate impact on great numbers of households, shifting the costs of these publicly funded programs onto the shoulders of families that can least take the burden.

The majority of Portland's residents can ill afford the costs of trying to close the deficit without damaging the regional economy further. Portland's unemployment rate is 7.9 percent. According to the Business Journal, 8.3 percent of Portland families live below the poverty level; for families with children the number is 12.9 percent, and 27.4 percent for single, divorced and separated women. If he gets his way, Mayor Hales’s austerity axe will continue to swing at the city's most vulnerable citizens.

Portland's top companies make hundreds of millions, if not billions, every year. In Oregon the share of total state income collected by the wealthiest 1 percent increased by 70 percent from 1979 to 2009. In contrast, during that same period, the bottom 80 percent of Oregonians saw their income decline.

In 2009 the highest effective state tax rate for corporations with profits over $10 million was less than 1 percent. For a middle income Oregon household, the average effective rate of payment was 4.1 percent.

If corporations paid the same rate of state and city income taxes that is expected of most citizens, there would be no deficit, no crisis, no need for cuts. Given the vast amount of untouched revenue tucked away in these corporate coffers, Hales’s call for public "sacrifice" to balance the city's budget amounts to a shell game to distract people from asking, "Where is the money?"

Portland is not broke. The problem is that those with the money are being let off the hook.

Special Arrangements

In addition, Portland's city budget is far from transparent. It is divided into a General Fund, which is where the so-called deficit is located, as well as Internal Service Funds (ISF). ISFs are unrestricted net assets of the city. They can be used for any purpose. The amount of money in this part of the budget has been steadily increasing. In 2010-2011, the ISF balance was $120.6 million.

But rather than using this money to benefit Portland's working class communities, the City Council keeps it stashed away for pet projects to lure wealthy investors to the city. Since the ISF lacks transparency and accountability, it is difficult to determine how the money in these funds is used; we only know that it isn't available when the tax paying public needs it.

Another way Portland's politicians stash away huge sums to benefit big business is through the use of Urban Renewal (UR). UR requires that money be spent on development projects in a certain area. The revenue created by this development, including property taxes, remains locked up in the area for decades — from 20 to 50 years.

UR taxes in 2010-2011 amounted to $35 million for the city of Portland alone. These funds can only be spent in the UR areas from which they were collected. Consequently, while the posh UR area of Portland's Pearl District enjoys more public funds than it needs, elsewhere in Portland school closures are looming, streets remain unpaved and infrastructure and park maintenance is done on the cheap, if at all.

Put simply, UR is a means of enriching developers and other corporate interests — like big contributors to politicians’ campaign funds — to the detriment of Portland's working class communities. The fact that this model, which results in widening inequality, continues to be pursued by those advocating cuts to public programs could not make more clear where these politicians’ allegiances lie.

While Mayor Hales is blaming the city's deficit on several factors, the math does not add up. When low corporate tax rates, the millions kept in shady city funds, and the revenue drain of development programs such as UR are taken into account, it becomes clear that Portland's deficit hawks are manufacturing a crisis in order to continue arrangements where workers are left to pay for big business’ greed.

Our Priorities, Our Budget

In addition to the "I feel your pain" displays by Mayor Hales towards those affected by his cuts, he will also employ the tactic of divide and conquer. Those threatened by these cuts will be told the lie that raising revenue by taxing big business and the wealthy is off the table. "The pie is only so big," promoters of the cuts moan, "you must decide your own priorities." And in this way they hope to set different communities and unions against one another.

It should be clear, for reasons already discussed, how false this storyline is. While there is likely more than a little padding in upper management that can be cut, and plenty of taxes that remain uncollected, the truth is that a real solution to Portland's deficit won't emerge until these priorities are confronted and turned around.

What would a budget that prioritizes peoples' needs look like? Rather than job cutting, it would fund job creation. Instead of slashing social programs, it would build a thriving and accountable public sector. And corporate interests would take second place behind the health of working class communities. A people's budget could easily be funded if the 1 percent paid their fair share in taxes and were not given the driver's seat in determining Portland's development and political policies.

To change business as usual in Portland will require mobilizing an independent grassroots social force to oppose Hales’s cuts and the corporate interests behind them. It will take a unified Labor and community movement capable of expanding its goals towards winning a people's budget.

The demands to unite such a movement must be those that the greatest numbers are willing to mobilize behind. "No Cuts! Tax the Rich!" would be a good place to start. While each union and community group has its own priorities, highlighting those which build the broadest unity in mass campaigns and rallies is the best way to bring these organizations' specific concerns and struggles to the greatest number.

With his austerity cuts, Mayor Hales has issued a challenge to the grassroots. A unified fightback is necessary to meet it. With such a movement it will be possible to shift the political dialogue towards measures that serve the vast majority of citizens. Without it, Portland will be left with Hales’s cuts and worse.

At the same time, a big fight is gearing up as Oregon's democratic governor has threatened cuts to public workers' jobs and retirement benefits, on the tail of passing emergency legislation to lock in Nike's absurdly low tax rate for 30 years. In building a citywide response, Labor and community groups will be strengthening their capacity to take on austerity at a statewide level as well.

Every city, county and statewide struggle against the corporate austerity attacks can set an example for and strengthen our ability to resist cuts to Medicare, Social Security and other socially needed federal programs. From this resistance a movement can develop with the ability not only to resist attacks -- but to fight for and implement policies that benefit all working people.

Mark Vorpahl is a union steward, social justice activist and a writer for Workers Action. He can be reached at Portland@workerscompass.org

Add new comment

Sign Up

Article Tabs

anti-fracking protests, Keep It In the Ground, protester arrests, undercover agents

Emails obtained through an open records act request show that the Lakewood Police Department in Colorado collected details about a BLM oil and gas lease protest from undercover officers as the event was being planned.

Greek privatizations, transit privatization, Panhellenic Railway Association, TrainOSE, water privatization, Thessaloniki Water Supply & Sewage, Greek austerity policies

Late last month, the Panhellenic Railway Association took to the streets to protest a slew of public transport privatizations scheduled to take place later this year. "The government defiantly and shamelessly gives away the national wealth," it said.

#WebOfDenial, climate denial, fossil fuel industry, Exxon climate lies

In the U.S. Senate, champions for climate action and accountability are loudly putting the blame on think tanks and denier-for-hire front groups that have created doubt about climate science.

Universal Credit, Citizen’s Advice Scotland, U.K. austerity policies, welfare benefits reform, Citizen Advice, New Policy Institute, welfare payment delays

Claimants are facing hefty delays in receiving benefits and unfair sanctions.

ISTANBUL, Turkey

Soldiers versus police versus a mob in the newsroom of Turkey’s most-watched news channel — and dozens of reporters to document it all.

This week we prepare activists for what they might encounter as they take to the streets for justice and equality.

Posted 4 days 8 hours ago
Sherry Hernandez, Senka Huskic, housing crisis, foreclosures crisis, mortgage-lending crisis, Countrywide, PennyMac, CitiMortgage, Trustee Corps, foreclosures fraud, banking crimes, TARP, HAMP

"If we had known from the beginning how corrupt the system was, we probably never would have started."

Posted 5 days 8 hours ago
Pakistan climate impacts, climate change in Pakistan, extreme flooding, glacial melt

Glaciers are melting, extreme floods are becoming commonplace, and the country's infrastructure is struggling to keep up as climactic changes wreak havoc, threatening people's daily existence across Pakistan.

Posted 6 days 7 hours ago
Greek privatizations, transit privatization, Panhellenic Railway Association, TrainOSE, water privatization, Thessaloniki Water Supply & Sewage, Greek austerity policies

Late last month, the Panhellenic Railway Association took to the streets to protest a slew of public transport privatizations scheduled to take place later this year. "The government defiantly and shamelessly gives away the national wealth," it said.

Posted 2 days 9 hours ago
#23ways, 23 ways, Black Lives Matter, police brutality, We Are Here Campaign

Beyoncé, Alicia Keys, Rihanna, Jennifer Hudson, Pink, Bono, and others explain why it's time to take action to heal the long history of systemic racism in America.

Posted 5 days 8 hours ago
Universal Credit, Citizen’s Advice Scotland, U.K. austerity policies, welfare benefits reform, Citizen Advice, New Policy Institute, welfare payment delays

Claimants are facing hefty delays in receiving benefits and unfair sanctions.

#WebOfDenial, climate denial, fossil fuel industry, Exxon climate lies

In the U.S. Senate, champions for climate action and accountability are loudly putting the blame on think tanks and denier-for-hire front groups that have created doubt about climate science.

anti-fracking protests, Keep It In the Ground, protester arrests, undercover agents

Emails obtained through an open records act request show that the Lakewood Police Department in Colorado collected details about a BLM oil and gas lease protest from undercover officers as the event was being planned.

“Reverse redlining” flooded communities of color with toxic mortgages, practically ensuring default.

Black Lives Matter, police brutality, police killings of blacks, police killings of Latinos, Andy Lopez, David Sal Silva, National Council of La Raza, Jorge Ramos, Latino activists, Latino Donor Collaborative, Community Alert Patrol, Chicano activists, Bl

Is the media to blame for Latinos’ absence in the debate about police-community relations?