Search form

A More Equal Economy Would Mean a Happier Society

A More Equal Economy Would Mean a Happier Society
Fri, 11/9/2012 - by Brad DeLong
This article originally appeared on San Francisco Chronicle

A third of a century ago, all of us economists confidently predicted that America would remain and even become more of a middle-class society. The high income and wealth inequality of the Gilded Age (1870-1929 ), we would have said, was a peculiar result of the first age of industrialization. Transformations in technology, public investments in education, a progressive tax system, a safety net, and the continued decline in discrimination on the basis of race and sex had made late-20th century America a much more equal place than early 20th century America, and would make early 21st century America even more equal — even more of a middle-class society — still.

We were wrong.

America today is at least as unequal as, and may be more unequal than, it was back at the start of the 20th century when Republicans such as President Theodore Roosevelt of New York condemned the power wielded by “malefactors of great wealth,” and Democrats such as perennial losing presidential candidate William Jennings Bryant of Nebraska denounced shadowy conspiracies that had somehow manipulated the financial system to rob the typical family of its proper share in America’s prosperity.

Four major and a host of minor factors have driven rising inequality over the past third of a century:

The progressivity of our tax system: we no longer tax the rich a significantly greater share of their income than we tax the middle class. The idea behind the cut in relative tax rates on the rich was that it would release blocked entrepreneurial energy and trigger a burst of more rapid economic growth. It did not happen: economic growth overall has been slower since President Ronald Reagan began the series of waves of tax cuts for the rich.

The decline in our willingness to invest in education: a generation ago, we were the best-educated country among the rich nations of the North Atlantic; today we rank 14th. With fewer well-educated people than the trend would have predicted, supply and demand have raised the salaries of the educated relative to trend; with more poorly educated people than the trend would have predicted, supply and demand have lowered the wages of the less-educated not just relative to trend but absolutely.

Add in more minor factors, such as the relative decline in the minimum wage and the coming of globalization, and the upshot is that the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tells us that the typical white American male with just a high school diploma earns less today than his predecessor of the late-1970s, even though the country as a whole is 70 percent richer per capita. Thus the top fifth of America today outstrips the rest much more than it did a generation ago: their incomes are higher than their predecessors’ as they have kept up with the 70 percent tide of economic growth, while the statistics say that the rest are more-or-less treading water.

But there is more: two more factors have widened inequality not between the top fifth of America and the rest but between the top fifth and the 1 percent, and even more the 0.1 percent and the 0.01 percent.

The information revolution has transformed us into a winner-take-all society, in which the most skilled and luckiest leverage their skills and luck across immense customer bases. In earlier centuries, Charles Dickens and Enrico Caruso were superstars but not superwealthy. Today Stephen King and Placido Domingo and Oprah Winfrey are superwealthy indeed. We saw this a century ago whenever luck and economies of scale in production and a continent-wide market all came together: Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller became super-rich. But our Bill Gates is, and Sam Walton was, superricher.

The shift of economic focus into sectors that do not add but subtract value: 3% of the American economy today is excessive private health care administrative costs, which produces nothing useful but transfers money away from insurance customers and doctors whose bills are not paid to insurance companies that do not pay them.

Some 4% of the American economy today is excessive financial services: less-informed savers and borrowers who should not be buying or selling sophisticated financial products they do not understand losing their money to those better able to judge risks and values.

We can see the impact of these last two factors in the Romney family dynasty. American Motors President and Michigan Gov. George Romney typically made $300,000 a year in the early 1960s, roughly 40 times the typical income of Americans of his day. Bain Capital President and Massachusetts Gov. W. Mitt Romney typically makes $20 million a year today, roughly 400 times the typical income of Americans now — and relative to those he regards as his Wall Street peers, W. Mitt Romney is a relatively poor man.

A more equal economy would be a happier economy. The time and energy and work devoted to making, toasting and serving a $40 bagel at the Four Seasons Hotel on 57th Street in Manhattan would, in a more equal America, buy a full dinner for four at Sizzler Steakhouse for a family for which going to Sizzler is a once-a-month treat — and produce more human happiness thereby. A more equal America would be one in which claims that America has or is approaching equality of opportunity would be less of a sick joke.

A more equal America would be one in which macroeconomic catastrophes like the current 2007-whenever episode that currently robs 1 in 12 usually-working Americans of his or her job would be less likely and less destructive. Those who see themselves as falling behind their peers are inevitably prone to take extra risks as they “gamble for resurrection.”

This is a very human drive: it applies to those who go double-or-nothing repeatedly and lose $5 billion for the investment bank they work for as well as those who commit 50 percent of their income to mortgage payments in the hope of grabbing some equity for themselves in a housing boom.

This also produces an economy in which there is too-much, too-risky debt around that borrowers must save to pay down and that creditors don’t dare spend because they fear it will vanish. And such an economy in which nearly everybody is trying to spend less than they earn is one that is prone to depression.

What can be done to make America a more equal, more middle-class, happier, less fragile and vulnerable economy with more real equality of opportunity?

We really don’t want to do anything to restrict globalization. America is still a rich country in a poor world, and we have a moral obligation not to use our economic weight to close off others’ roads to prosperity.

We do want an America with higher taxes on the rich: when market income is more unequal, taxes on the rich should be higher to equalize — but because money talks and, after Chief Justice John Roberts’ intervention in American politics in the Citizens United case talks louder than ever, that is not the way it works. The road to a better tax system now looks like it will take at least a generation and require substantial turnover of the Supreme Court before it can even begin.

We can’t do anything about changing technologies that have produced the winner-take-all economy.

We can tax and regulate our health-care and financial systems to shift the resources of the 7% of the American economy that is currently subtracting from our national prosperity into something useful.

And we could renew our national commitment to education: we could strive to once again make America — and not Germany or Korea or someplace else — the country where education and thus roads to upward mobility are most comprehensive, best and cheapest.

But — and I hope this is just the growing pessimism of the middle-aged as more and more often your first thought on awakening is “my back!” — I don’t think that we will.

Article Tabs

How will the state pay for these new tax cuts that primarily benefit the rich? By raising taxes on the poor, of course.

From Spain's grassroots city mayors to the Mexican Citizens' Movement, the worldwide network of rebel territories is continuing to grow.

bank bailouts, Wall Street crimes, Federal Reserve, Ben Bernanke, Great Recession, illegal foreclosures, banking crimes

The former Fed chair says that, in addition to banks and corporations paying billions in fines for their illegal activities that triggered the economic meltdown and Great Recession, individuals should have also been held accountable.

How can we pretend to be mystified about gun violence within our borders when violence as a concept and as actual hardware is the #1 U.S. export?

Detroit foreclosures, Wayne County Tax Foreclosure Auction, tax foreclosure auctions, online auction, foreclosed homes

The largest known municipal foreclosure sale to date, the Detroit home sell-off could be a modern take on Manifest Destiny – luring would-be frontiersmen and speculators from across the world to try their hand at “buying Detroit.”, Megaupload, Kim Dotcom, civil forfeiture, money laundering, unequal justice, Internet freedom

Vast resources of the U.S. government are being deployed at the bidding of the entertainment industry, which saw its profits threatened by Internet pioneers like Dotcom and his Megaupload content-sharing empire.

Posted 6 days 21 hours ago

This week, from med students to female priests, fasters to the monopoly man, we've got a helluva lineup – first up, let's talk Medicare and why it shouldn't be so ageist.

Posted 6 days 21 hours ago

How will the state pay for these new tax cuts that primarily benefit the rich? By raising taxes on the poor, of course.

Posted 22 hours 4 min ago
war machine, Paris climate summit, carbon emissions, military carbon emissions, weapons for oil, war fueling climate change, perpetual war, 1% profits

Oil and the war business are as connected to each other as they are tied to capitalism – which is why, to tackle climate change, we need to dismantle both.

Posted 5 days 20 hours ago

The idea for an international bank had already been explored to some extent by people like the economist John Maynard Keynes. But the idea for the bank truly took off during the Young Conference in 1929, when the Allies were attempting to exact Germany’s reparations debts for WWI.

Posted 4 days 21 hours ago

Since it's the takeover of our democratic process by big money that makes most Americans angry, Podemos is a story from which Americans could take heart.

mountaintop coal removal, Don Blankenship, Massey Energy Co., coal mine explosions, coal mine disasters, Mine Safety and Health Administration, Alpha Natural Resources Inc., United Mine Workers of America

Prosecutors charge that Don Blankenship lied to financial regulators and conspired to violate safety regulations before April 5, 2010, when a massive blast in the Upper Big Branch mine in Montcoal, West Virginia killed 29 men.

money in politics, Super PACs, political action committees, Citizens United, money is not speech, Larry Lessig, campaign finance reform

To watch American politics today is to watch money speaking – and the sums involved dwarf those in any other mature democracy.

Barack Obama, UN General Assembly, Daesh, ISIS, ISIL, Vladimir Putin, Syria civil war, Bashar al-Assad

At the UN on Monday, a scene not unlike a heavy-weight boxing match in Vegas played out, as the rich and famous gathered ringside to watch a long anticipated slugfest between two titans that could very well have been fixed.

Detroit foreclosures, Wayne County Tax Foreclosure Auction, tax foreclosure auctions, online auction, foreclosed homes

The largest known municipal foreclosure sale to date, the Detroit home sell-off could be a modern take on Manifest Destiny – luring would-be frontiersmen and speculators from across the world to try their hand at “buying Detroit.”

Sign Up