Read

User menu

Search form

California Financial: Let's Take the Initiative and Create A Public Bank

California Financial: Let's Take the Initiative and Create A Public Bank
Thu, 8/20/2015 - by Stephen J. Butler
This article originally appeared on San Jose Mercury News

I personally think the time has come to set wheels in motion to organize a state-owned bank here in California. North Dakota has operated its own bank since the early 1900s and it has made money for taxpayers while strengthening the state's own regional banks. The net effect has been to keep bank profits in North Dakota. The only losers have been the "too-big-to-fail" banks that would otherwise have enjoyed making the spread on money borrowed by, and throughout, the state.

Of course, there is little political will to organize anything this effective in California because the banking lobby deploys too much money throughout the political process. However, our state's initiative process offers voters an option to do an end-run around elected officials. We could take a major step in offering an alternative to the predations of Wall Street's major banking institutions while generating a predictable source of revenue for the state.

I floated the idea of a public bank in an earlier column, but what set me off this time was an email I received from a reader, age 73, who was faced with eviction after doing battle for six years with one of the major financial institutions -- the latter of which is only still in business today because of a taxpayers' bailout back in 2008. All these banks have lost sight of the fact that we have every right to treat them as a public utility.

But back to our embattled reader: After having added to the principal at a rate of $1,000 per month, which was illegal at the time, the bank has now renegotiated with loan payments of $2,000 per month that rise by $200 per month in 2016, $400 per month in 2017 and $500 per month in 2018. The lawyer working with this couple has described their predicament as "the worst predatory loan he has ever seen."

I had thought that situations like this were behind us until earlier this month when the New York Times ran two articles on the extent to which banks were still beating up on their borrowers. One bank was found to have rejected 87 percent of requests for loan modifications while, at the same time, denials were highly profitable thanks to the continuation of loan servicing fees.

Thanks to organizations like the Public Banking Institute, there is a growing national movement to consider the adoption of public banks. It is prompted, in part, by the inability of elected officials to make much headway against the forces of lobbyists in Washington or at state levels. How else can you explain the fact that one major bank today is back to having over $35 trillion in derivatives? That means that we're all back to ensuring that institutions backing those bets are all good for the money. It's like "Oofty Goofty" always bouncing back up.

The only antidote is to establish a parallel banking system owned by citizens much like the Resolution Trust Corporation that the federal government operated during the Depression and World War II. When it finally closed its doors, under pressure from the banking industry, it had made over $600 million in profit for the United States -- and that was back when $600 million was a lot of money.

Meanwhile, with North Dakota as an example, the most progress could probably be accomplished here in California where we have the advantage of the initiative process. If nothing else, it would be illustrative and entertaining to see who, exactly, would be falling all over themselves to fight the initiative -- and to see how much money they would spend in an attempt to quash a standard of comparison.

Originally published by San Jose Mercury News

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Sign Up

Article Tabs

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

The tragic shooting of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo is just the latest example of ICE having a fundamental disrespect for human life — further proving why the agency should be stripped of funding and shut down, and its rank-and-file agents and leadership prosecuted.

While the U.S., EU and their allies are enabling Rojava—the strongest force against Islamic State— to fall, it is vital for internationalists to continue to support this beacon of democracy and liberation.

June 23, 2026 may be remembered as the beginning of the end of the Democratic Party establishment.

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

We can still celebrate success while simultaneously putting a cap on net worth.

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

Much like the resistance to AI data centers, the opposition to Flock surveillance cameras has brought the left and the right together against billionaires who are trying to force America into becoming even more of a police state.

Much like the resistance to AI data centers, the opposition to Flock surveillance cameras has brought the left and the right together against billionaires who are trying to force America into becoming even more of a police state.

Posted 1 month 4 weeks ago

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

Posted 1 month 4 weeks ago

We can still celebrate success while simultaneously putting a cap on net worth.

Posted 1 month 2 weeks ago

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

Posted 2 weeks 6 days ago

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

Posted 3 weeks 1 day ago

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.