Read

User menu

Search form

How Organized Labor's Allegiance to Establishment Democrats is Killing Unions

How Organized Labor's Allegiance to Establishment Democrats is Killing Unions
Fri, 11/20/2015 - by C. Robert Gibson

Hillary Clinton's latest union endorsement — this time, from the 2.1 million member Service Employees International Union (SEIU) — has, once again, been an example of union leadership prioritizing political connections in high places over the best interests of its members.

As In These Times reported, the SEIU endorsement has angered local chapters so much that they're breaking off from the main union and endorsing Bernie Sanders, as they already have in New Hampshire, the first official presidential primary state. Rank-and-file dues-paying members of the SEIU said the executive board's announcement came too early, and point out that while Clinton's proposal for a $12 an hour minimum wage flies in the face of the SEIU's own Fight For $15 campaign. Both of Clinton's opponents in the Democratic primary, Bernie Sanders and Martin O'Malley, have gotten behind the call for a $15 an hour minimum wage.

The SEIU's Facebook page has been full of angry rants from dues-paying members upset with the endorsement. Daily Kos collected some of the more descriptive posts from the page's wall:

“Please retract the SEIU endorsement for Hillary Clinton. She does NOT represent the average working American. She takes funding from Wall Street PLUS foreign donations as well as contributions from Private Prison Corporations. So just exactly who does she work for?" Wrote Cathy Bosell Haye.

“This is scandalous, shameful, counterintuitive, problematic, defeating, and divisive. Pathetic," wrote Angel Rodriguez. "SEIU's biggest national campaign is the Fight for $15 and a union. Across the country, we are organizing workers to strike and demand a $15 minimum wage. DESPITE THIS: Hillary Clinton is on public record as opposing a federal minimum wage of $15 per hour.’’

So if the SEIU's endorsement wasn't due to Clinton's progressive values, why did they endorse her?

Other unions that have endorsed Clinton's 2016 campaign paint a clearer picture. The Association of Federal, State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) also endorsed Clinton earlier. As Huffington Post reported, AFSCME was largely responsible for the rise of Bill Clinton in 1992, and endorsed Clinton in 2007 during her last attempt at the Democratic nomination. And just as it happened with the SEIU endorsement, AFSCME members revolted at the national leadership's decision to endorse Clinton, saying an endorsement this early only served to divide members, and that union leadership should instead focus on issues that unite the union's members.

Clinton's first union endorsement came from the American Federation of Teachers (AFT), which represents public K-12 teachers as well as college-level instructors. As with SEIU and AFSCME, AFT members resisted the leadership's endorsement of Clinton, as it only served to stifle debate that is essential to the Democratic process. A petition circulated by AFT members calling for national leadership to pull back their endorsement of Clinton has garnered over 5,500 signatures as of the time of this writing.

As CounterPunch pointed out in this article, unions have steadily been declining as labor leaders continue to implore members to trust "friendly" parties rather than try to make the unions a political force in and of themselves. Curiously, over the past 60 years, union membership has declined at the same time as wages have stagnated or dropped. In 2012 research from the Economic Policy Institute's research found that the share of the workforce that had union representation dropped from 26 percent to 13 percent between 1973 and 2011. That time period covers 3 Democratic administrations, and 4 Republican administrations. Regardless of the party in power, union membership and wages continued to decline.

The numbers bear out — labor unions' longtime ties to establishment Democratic politicians hasn't won them more membership, and hasn't grown the middle class. On the contrary, both parties have overseen large gains in wealth for the top 1 percent of Americans, and the simultaneous evaporation of the middle class. If labor unions really want to hold power again, they should focus instead on pushing members of both parties to support their goals, rather than aligning with politicians to have a seat at the table of power. The future of organized labor may depend on it.

 

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Sign Up

Article Tabs

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

The tragic shooting of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo is just the latest example of ICE having a fundamental disrespect for human life — further proving why the agency should be stripped of funding and shut down, and its rank-and-file agents and leadership prosecuted.

While the U.S., EU and their allies are enabling Rojava—the strongest force against Islamic State— to fall, it is vital for internationalists to continue to support this beacon of democracy and liberation.

June 23, 2026 may be remembered as the beginning of the end of the Democratic Party establishment.

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

We can still celebrate success while simultaneously putting a cap on net worth.

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

Much like the resistance to AI data centers, the opposition to Flock surveillance cameras has brought the left and the right together against billionaires who are trying to force America into becoming even more of a police state.

Much like the resistance to AI data centers, the opposition to Flock surveillance cameras has brought the left and the right together against billionaires who are trying to force America into becoming even more of a police state.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

We can still celebrate success while simultaneously putting a cap on net worth.

Posted 1 month 1 week ago

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

Posted 2 weeks 4 days ago

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

Posted 2 weeks 6 days ago

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.