Read

User menu

Search form

How YouTube Rightwing Extremists Became the Internet Mainstream

How YouTube Rightwing Extremists Became the Internet Mainstream
Thu, 10/18/2018 - by Agata Popeda

Exploring so called “alternative media” on YouTube will make you end up watching white supremacists. Both Google’s greed and the carelessness of mainstream conservatives are to blame.

In January 2018, I interviewed a pro-Kremlin YouTube personality, Inessa Sinchougova, who captured the attention of 100,000 Americans with her edited translations of Putin’s speeches and interviews. Two years after launching her channel, Sinchougova reportedly has more views on YouTube than her favorite singer, Rihanna.

But Rihanna is not the only one underperforming on the mega Internet channel that, since 2006, has belonged to Google. After spending some time on the platform, it becomes clear to even the casual observer that politically YouTube now belongs to the far-right – just like Twitter largely, with one notable presidential exception, belongs to the left.

According to The Guardian, during the 2016 presidential election, YouTube was dominated by anti-Hillary content because of an algorithm, not anyone’s conscious decision. But to say that popularity of the Parkland shooting conspiracy clips or pseudo-scientific debates on the differences between races reflects only on our choices would be a mistake, too.

What we are in fact dealing with here is what the Oxford Internet Institute calls “computational propaganda”: the work of an artificial intelligence seeking profit and, on the way there, cracking the code to our worst desires and fears.

One of the company's early engineers, Guillaume Chaslot, was sufficiently terrified with what he had helped to create that he quit his job at Google and started his own company, Algo Transparency, with a mission to demonstrate how the YouTube algorithm works.

In March, The New York Times published an op-ed by sociologist Zeynep Tufekci, who described her own experiments with YouTube and the unexpected consequences of “selling our attention to companies.”

As most of us know, YouTube videos are played in chains, as playlists – in fact, a new video starts playing automatically a few seconds after the previous one ends. Tufekci observed that the algorithm figured out that the best way to keep us watching is to keep feeding us with more and more radical and incendiary content.

“Given its billion or so users, YouTube may be one of the most powerful radicalizing instruments of the 21st century,” Tufekci said.

Google is aware of the problem for some time now and, just like other tech giants, it’s struggling to solve the problem without giving up money. YouTube has a Partner Program within which content creators get a proportion of advertising revenue. You have to have 4,000 “watch hours” and at least 1,000 subscribers – but the content you produce, until recently, didn’t matter.

In January, this program was modified and many racist, misogynist and harassing videos were flagged and not paid for, even if they had many views. Around the same time, the pro-Putin commentator Inessa Sinchougova and many other controversial YouTubers were forced to open accounts on Patreon, a membership platform that allows fans to support content creators with monthly fees, in order to continue to support themselves as full-time vloggers.

Then, in September, the Data & Society Research Institute released a study shedding more light on the YouTube radicalization phenomenon. Researcher Rebecca Lewis identified a so-called “Alternative Influence Network... an assortment of scholars, media pundits, and internet celebrities who use YouTube to promote a range of political positions, from mainstream versions of libertarianism and conservatism, all the way to overt white nationalism.”

While their views differ, these "influencers" all share a fundamental contempt for progressive politics and contemporary social justice movements. “For this reason,” Lewis wrote, “I consider their collective position ‘reactionary,’ as it is defined by its opposition to visions of social progress.”

The study showed that YouTube right-wingers adopted techniques and tactics developed by YouTube brand influencers, such as personal growth confession (“coming out” as conservatives) or cross-promotion (collaborations across ideological lines).

The latter trick seems to be particularly problematic. While mainstream members of the network, like conservative political commentator Ben Shapiro, or the former Young Turks commentator David Rubin, “typically don’t subscribe to alt-right or white nationalist ideals, they do host those who do under very friendly terms,” Lewis reported.

One reason YouTubers' extreme popularity is because they appear available to their audience; their authenticity, the same feature that brought us Trump’s presidency, is perceived as credible. Moreover, on YouTube, followers are invited to participate in the process.

As BuzzFeed reported, one of the popular features used during YouTube debates, “super chat," where users pay to have their comments highlighted on the screen during the stream, is full of hate speech.

The semblance of friendliness plays a crucial role in YouTube alternative media. the reputation of traditional media is replaced with social ties and trust. As independent reporter Tim Pool argued, media outlets' institutional reputation can actually be seen as a cover for bad journalism.

In her report, Lewis referred to another scholar, Daniel Kreiss, who analyzed readers of Fox News and Breitbart News and concluded that they think of the outlets as their family – a place where they, “outcasts” and “underdogs,” can feel at home.

The concept of underdog is particularly popular among political influencers on YouTube: the shared sense of being under attack, targeted by the mainstream media and by YouTube itself.

On Sept. 24, after months of silence, Sinchougova posted another video on her channel. In the new video she referred to the piece I wrote about her, calling the article “bullying and harassment.” She also shared a letter she recently received from YouTube.

The platform informed her that during a review, the team of specialists looked over the videos she had been uploading and found that they were “not in line” with the YouTube Partner Program policy.

As of the date of the letter, Sinchougova's channel is not eligible for monetization. But many others are doing just fine.

Sign Up

Article Tabs

Venezuela crisis, Venezuela regime change, Nicolas Maduro, Donald Trump, Washington geopolitical aims, U.S. overseas intervention

Our country is so divided, on so many issues, yet intervening in foreign countries is a united addiction we just can’t tear ourselves away from.

Senegal protests, Y’en A Marre movement, New Type of Senegalese, African social protests, economic justice, ending corruption, African protest movements, Senegal democratic movement

The Y’en a Marre ("We Are Fed Up") movement, which traveled the country raising awareness about the need to vote, played a crucial role helping defeat Senegal's two-term president in 2012.

Imagine a fracked gas pipeline going straight through New York Harbor...

Fears that Ireland will stand fast on its border claims are among the most pressing concerns still dogging the Brexit deal, which could ultimately force a new referendum.

Brexit chaos, no-deal Brexit, U.K. homelessness, U.K. hate crimes, U.K. xenophobia, rise in hate crimes, rise in homelessness, Leave campaign, Jo Cox murder

As Brexit bedlam intensifies and Britain edges closer to its agonizing E.U. departure date of March 29, grim reports are surfacing about the real impacts the move will have on U.K. citizens' safety and well being.

Venezuela crisis, Venezuela regime change, Nicolas Maduro, Donald Trump, Washington geopolitical aims, U.S. overseas intervention

Our country is so divided, on so many issues, yet intervening in foreign countries is a united addiction we just can’t tear ourselves away from.

Senegal protests, Y’en A Marre movement, New Type of Senegalese, African social protests, economic justice, ending corruption, African protest movements, Senegal democratic movement

The Y’en a Marre ("We Are Fed Up") movement, which traveled the country raising awareness about the need to vote, played a crucial role helping defeat Senegal's two-term president in 2012.

Imagine a fracked gas pipeline going straight through New York Harbor...

An endangered silverback high mountain gorilla from Sabyinyo family walks inside a forest in the Volcanoes National Park near Kinigi, north-western Rwanda. Photograph: Thomas Mukoya/Reuters

The vast majority of the world’s largest species are being pushed towards extinction, with the killing of the heftiest animals for meat and body parts the leading cause of decline, according to a new study.

wealth inequality, income inequality, wealth gap, tax the rich, ultra-millionaire tax

"U.S. wealth concentration seems to have returned to levels last seen during the Roaring Twenties."

Imagine a fracked gas pipeline going straight through New York Harbor...

Posted 3 days 18 hours ago
Black Lives Matter, black homeowners, Section 8 housing, BLM-Louisville

In Louisville, the group is purchasing vacant homes for low-income families to promote stability in the community and fight gentrification.

Posted 5 days 18 hours ago

Fears that Ireland will stand fast on its border claims are among the most pressing concerns still dogging the Brexit deal, which could ultimately force a new referendum.

Posted 5 days 18 hours ago

As the March for Our Lives movement enters its second year, it would benefit to have black faces at the forefront to expand the narrative around gun reform.

Posted 4 days 19 hours ago
"Folks are gathering to talk about the plan to win guaranteed healthcare.Next steps involve knocking on doors, phone banks—various ways of engaging our communities to get involved," said National Nurses United executive director Bonnie Castillo. (Photo: N

"As nurses, we understand the need for guaranteed healthcare for everyone. That's why we are fighting to win Medicare for All and joining thousands at barnstorms across the country."

Posted 5 days 18 hours ago
Senegal protests, Y’en A Marre movement, New Type of Senegalese, African social protests, economic justice, ending corruption, African protest movements, Senegal democratic movement

The Y’en a Marre ("We Are Fed Up") movement, which traveled the country raising awareness about the need to vote, played a crucial role helping defeat Senegal's two-term president in 2012.

Black Lives Matter, black homeowners, Section 8 housing, BLM-Louisville

In Louisville, the group is purchasing vacant homes for low-income families to promote stability in the community and fight gentrification.

Venezuela crisis, Venezuela regime change, Nicolas Maduro, Donald Trump, Washington geopolitical aims, U.S. overseas intervention

Our country is so divided, on so many issues, yet intervening in foreign countries is a united addiction we just can’t tear ourselves away from.

Denver teacher strike, teacher pay, teacher walkouts, nationwide teacher strikes, public school conditions

Denver’s teachers started picketing before the start of the school day and students crossed through the picket lines on their way to class in some locations.

wealth inequality, income inequality, wealth gap, tax the rich, ultra-millionaire tax

"U.S. wealth concentration seems to have returned to levels last seen during the Roaring Twenties."