Read

User menu

Search form

Twitter Sues U.S. Government Over Surveillance Disclosure Rules

Twitter Sues U.S. Government Over Surveillance Disclosure Rules
Thu, 10/9/2014 - by Andrea Chang and Paresh Dave
This article originally appeared on Los Angeles Times

Twitter Inc. is the latest tech giant to sue the U.S. government for the right to reveal the scope of government surveillance of its users.

The San Francisco microblogging site filed suit against the Department of Justice and the FBI on Tuesday, saying it was being "unconstitutionally restricted by statutes that prohibit and even criminalize" the public disclosure of such requests.

Twitter hopes to be able to publish a "full transparency" report, which details the kind and number of national security letters and Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act court orders the company has received from the government.

"It's our belief that we are entitled under the 1st Amendment to respond to our users' concerns and to the statements of U.S. government officials by providing information about the scope of U.S. government surveillance," Twitter lawyer Benjamin Lee said in a blog post. "We should be free to do this in a meaningful way, rather than in broad, inexact ranges."

The suit, filed with the U.S. District Court in Northern California, asks the court to declare the restrictions unconstitutional under the 1st Amendment.

The always-contentious issue of government spying turned super heated after Edward Snowden's disclosures that the National Security Agency routinely snoops on the electronic communications of American citizens. That created a public relations crisis for social media firms such as Twitter, Google Inc., Facebook Inc. and others, with users suspicious that the sites were sharing their information with the government.

"It makes people think twice about using your service because it's government central," said Steven Roosa, co-chair of law firm Holland & Knight's data privacy and security team. "Companies feel an obligation to push back against the state surveillance machine."

Last year Microsoft Corp., Google and other major tech firms sued the government, contending the 1st Amendment gave them the right to disclose more information about their reluctant role in government spying. The Obama administration agreed to relax some of its disclosure rules in a January settlement with the firms; in return, the tech companies dropped their respective lawsuits.

At the time, Atty. Gen. Eric Holder and Director of National Intelligence James Clapper said communications providers would be permitted to disclose "more information than ever before" under the new rules.

The administration agreed to allow more detailed disclosures about the number of national security orders and requests issued to communications providers, and the number of customer accounts targeted under those orders and requests, including the underlying legal authorities.

On Tuesday, Department of Justice spokeswoman Emily Pierce reiterated that the agency was actively working with tech firms on better transparency.

"Earlier this year, the government addressed similar concerns raised in a lawsuit brought by several major tech companies," Pierce said. "There, the parties worked collaboratively to allow tech companies to provide broad information government requests while also protecting national security."

The Justice Department noted that AT&T, Microsoft, Google and Facebook have released transparency reports that contain reporting in unprecedented detail.

Twitter appears to think such compromises aren't good enough, and took its case to court to get a ruling fully in its favor.

"Twitter is concerned the settlement from January really doesn't give them the ability to give the public useful information," said Nate Cardozo, staff attorney at Electronic Frontier Foundation. "I think it's pretty clear a judge will find this an unconstitutional restraint. I would be more than surprised if Twitter backed down."

Others have questioned whether Twitter filed the lawsuit largely to drum up public goodwill.

"This is more of a PR play, a marketing play to show their customers that they care about their privacy," said Sharon Vardi, chief marketing officer of Securonix, which crunches data to identify computer security threats.

Kevin Bankston, policy director of the New America Foundation's Open Technology Institute, said that if Twitter prevails in court, it would be a win-win situation "regardless of what the data shows."

"If they are not making a lot of requests, that helps reassure users of Twitter because users' trust has been shaken by the NSA revelations," he said. "If it shows broad or expansive use of a specific authority, that could spur change in law by Congress."

Originally published by Los Angeles Times

Sign Up

Article Tabs

gun violence, sexual harassment, fracking, universal healthcare

Check out these uplifting tales in an age of diminished expectations.

participatory budgeting, citizen decision-making, Porto Alegre, Brazil

Citizen control of spending decisions means communities decide what their city does and does not do with public funds. For 30 years the process has worked in Brazil, and now it's spreading rapidly.

Did you know that showering less will save some water—sadly, not millions of gallons that fracking operations use in a day—nor will it keep your water safe from contamination—or your house from exploding

Greek economic crisis, Greek bailout, Syriza party, Greek austerity measures, E.U. bailouts, Alexis Tsipras

Poverty, privatizations, debt – in Greece, which just officially "ended" its bailout program, the silent majority can't let go their fear that this might just be the prelude to something worse yet to come.

California, privatization, PG&E, investor-owned utilities, energy utilities, fire risk, fire damage, Global Climate Action Summit, public banks, energy prices, consumer fees

Oil companies heat and dry up the planet, power companies start fires on the dried up land – and we pay the bills.

gun violence, sexual harassment, fracking, universal healthcare

Check out these uplifting tales in an age of diminished expectations.

A 2016 demonstration in Manhattan's Zuccotti Park, where the Occupy Wall Street movement started five years earlier. (Corinne Segal / pbs.org)

We live in a new feudalism. We have been stripped of political power. Workers are trapped in menial jobs, forced into crippling debt and paid stagnant or declining wages. Where will this end?

participatory budgeting, citizen decision-making, Porto Alegre, Brazil

Citizen control of spending decisions means communities decide what their city does and does not do with public funds. For 30 years the process has worked in Brazil, and now it's spreading rapidly.

bank bailouts, criminal executives, bank crimes, foreclosure crisis, subprime mortgages, derivatives market, too big to fail

Here's Why No One Went to Jail After the 2008 Financial Crisis. To many people, this is the single most frustrating post-crisis question.

Did you know that showering less will save some water—sadly, not millions of gallons that fracking operations use in a day—nor will it keep your water safe from contamination—or your house from exploding

California, privatization, PG&E, investor-owned utilities, energy utilities, fire risk, fire damage, Global Climate Action Summit, public banks, energy prices, consumer fees

Oil companies heat and dry up the planet, power companies start fires on the dried up land – and we pay the bills.

Posted 4 days 7 hours ago
participatory budgeting, citizen decision-making, Porto Alegre, Brazil

Citizen control of spending decisions means communities decide what their city does and does not do with public funds. For 30 years the process has worked in Brazil, and now it's spreading rapidly.

Posted 1 day 8 hours ago
“We just want to be able to take care of ourselves as men and women, in this Department of Corrections,” a strike participant from a South Carolina prison said.Photograph by David Paul Morris / Bloomberg / Getty

Wages for incarcerated workers are typically cents per hour, and several states—Alabama, Arkansas, Mississippi, Texas, and South Carolina—use prisoner labor without paying them at all.

Posted 3 days 7 hours ago
Occupy Wall Street, OWS, Occupy protests, Zuccotti Park, wealth inequality, Occupy anniversary

How a movement that eschewed electoral politics is now showing up everywhere in the 2018 progressive resurgence.

Posted 4 days 6 hours ago
too big to fail, public banks, public banking, Bank of North Dakota, financial crisis

When the next crisis hits, the public will once again be called upon to step in and bail out Wall Street. We need to start seriously preparing an alternative response: public banks.

Posted 4 days 7 hours ago
bank bailouts, criminal executives, bank crimes, foreclosure crisis, subprime mortgages, derivatives market, too big to fail

Here's Why No One Went to Jail After the 2008 Financial Crisis. To many people, this is the single most frustrating post-crisis question.

too big to fail, public banks, public banking, Bank of North Dakota, financial crisis

When the next crisis hits, the public will once again be called upon to step in and bail out Wall Street. We need to start seriously preparing an alternative response: public banks.

Greek economic crisis, Greek bailout, Syriza party, Greek austerity measures, E.U. bailouts, Alexis Tsipras

Poverty, privatizations, debt – in Greece, which just officially "ended" its bailout program, the silent majority can't let go their fear that this might just be the prelude to something worse yet to come.

California, privatization, PG&E, investor-owned utilities, energy utilities, fire risk, fire damage, Global Climate Action Summit, public banks, energy prices, consumer fees

Oil companies heat and dry up the planet, power companies start fires on the dried up land – and we pay the bills.

central banks, U.S. Federal Reserve, Dodd-Frank Act, nationalizing banks, bank bailouts, financial crash

"Central banks buying stocks are effectively nationalizing U.S. corporations just to maintain the illusion that their 'recovery' plan is working."