Read

User menu

Search form

Hawaii's Fight Against GMO's Rages On

Hawaii's Fight Against GMO's Rages On
Tue, 6/21/2016 - by JESSICA KNOBLAUCH
This article originally appeared on Earthjustice

Last week, Hawaii counties were back in court to defend their right to protect themselves from genetically engineered (GE) crops and the harmful pesticides that they’re modified to withstand. At stake is whether communities have a say over what goes on in their own backyards. But the Big Ag industry would have you believe these cases are about protecting upstanding companies from hostile anti-GE activists and their senseless acts of vandalism.

Before we get to that ridiculous notion, why has the GE debate landed in Hawaii in the first place? Even though most people know the Aloha State for its beautiful beaches, world-class surfing and delicious Kona coffee, the islands are also ground zero for GE crops. Hawaii’s year-round warm weather is attractive to beachgoers—and to agricultural companies that like to plant experimental crops as many times a year as possible. Today, Hawaii has more experimental field trials of GE crops than any other state in the nation.

While the debate over whether GE foods are safe to eat rages on across the country, Hawaii’s people are experiencing firsthand the deleterious environmental and health effects of GE crops and their pesticide counterparts. In Kauaʻi, for example, there have been several instances of schoolchildren and other residents suffering symptoms of pesticide exposure after GE crops were sprayed with toxic chemicals like the pesticide chlorpyrifos, a potent neurotoxin.

Despite their ongoing threat, Hawaii’s authorities have dragged their heels on regulating GE crops. A few years back, the counties stepped in, with Kaua'i, Maui and Hawaii all approving ordinances to help rein in GE crops.

On Kaua‘i, legislators passed an ordinance requiring large agricultural users of restricted use pesticides to disclose what they spray, notify before they spray and not spray near sensitive areas, like schools and waterways. It also requires growers of GE crops to disclose after the fact what they grew, and where.

On Hawaii, the only major island that has not seen significant incursions by the genetic engineering industry, the county passed a moratorium on expansion of GE crops, except for papaya.

In Maui County, where fields of GE crops also are widespread (especially on rural Moloka‘i), residents gathered thousands of signatures and passed an initiative that puts a moratorium on the cultivation of GE crops.

After the ordinances were approved, global agrochemical companies like Monsanto and Syngenta successfully sued to prevent the measures from taking effect. The counties and Earthjustice appealed, and all three cases were presented at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last week.

All of the cases come down to the question of preemption—whether the counties’ new regulations conflict with existing state or federal regulations. Earthjustice and its clients don’t believe that they do, and just because the state can regulate something doesn’t mean that the county cannot, says attorney Paul Achitoff.

But just in case their preemption argument didn’t work, the seed companies also threw in some fear-based reasoning for good measure. Syngenta’s attorney claimed that the company is afraid of what will happen if people are allowed to know where and when GE crops are planted.

Says Achitoff, “The industry has being playing the ‘vandalism’ card for at least the past 15 years to oppose any form of disclosure to the public, as though secrecy were its only effective tool to fight it—as opposed to, you know, walls, fences, security guards, monitoring systems and all the other tools everyone else uses to protect their property.”

Achitoff adds that there are many hundreds of acres of fields in Hawaii well known to be dedicated to GE crops that no one has tampered with.

The larger question, of course, goes beyond vandalism. It’s about whether people have the right, through their local government, to protect themselves from the impacts of GE crops when federal and state government won’t step in to help them.

Originally published by Earthjustice

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Sign Up

Article Tabs

Based on details that have emerged about Trump’s presidential agenda, the far-right Heritage Foundation plans for the next GOP president to have all the tools necessary to demolish multicultural democracy and establish a white, Christian ethnostate that imposes a gender apartheid not unlike the Taliban’s Afghanistan.

Donald Trump, Hitler

Like Hitler, Trump has a unique command of propaganda, a captivating public presence, and he knows how to drive home narratives beneficial to him and harmful to his enemies.

Trump’s brand of hyper-nationalism combined with the intense consolidation of executive power follows the same playbook as fascistic leaders in other countries like India,Russia, Hungary, Turkey, Egypt, Italy and Argentina, among others.

The Florida governor’s humiliating loss has a dark undertone: Most Republicans, and many independents, apparently have a craving for the unchecked lawless vengeance that Trump has promised if he wins a second term.

Are we truly “stuck with” this Supreme Court for the next quarter of a century? Not if we abolish the Electoral College and reimagine the way presidential elections are conducted.

Based on details that have emerged about Trump’s presidential agenda, the far-right Heritage Foundation plans for the next GOP president to have all the tools necessary to demolish multicultural democracy and establish a white, Christian ethnostate that imposes a gender apartheid not unlike the Taliban’s Afghanistan.

Donald Trump, Hitler

Like Hitler, Trump has a unique command of propaganda, a captivating public presence, and he knows how to drive home narratives beneficial to him and harmful to his enemies.

Trump’s brand of hyper-nationalism combined with the intense consolidation of executive power follows the same playbook as fascistic leaders in other countries like India,Russia, Hungary, Turkey, Egypt, Italy and Argentina, among others.

The Florida governor’s humiliating loss has a dark undertone: Most Republicans, and many independents, apparently have a craving for the unchecked lawless vengeance that Trump has promised if he wins a second term.

The case against ‘Cop City’ protesters follows the pattern of Republican abuse of the legal system to create false equivalences that advance their political narrative.

Based on details that have emerged about Trump’s presidential agenda, the far-right Heritage Foundation plans for the next GOP president to have all the tools necessary to demolish multicultural democracy and establish a white, Christian ethnostate that imposes a gender apartheid not unlike the Taliban’s Afghanistan.

Posted 2 weeks 12 hours ago

Trump’s brand of hyper-nationalism combined with the intense consolidation of executive power follows the same playbook as fascistic leaders in other countries like India,Russia, Hungary, Turkey, Egypt, Italy and Argentina, among others.

Posted 1 month 1 week ago
Donald Trump, Hitler

Like Hitler, Trump has a unique command of propaganda, a captivating public presence, and he knows how to drive home narratives beneficial to him and harmful to his enemies.

Posted 1 month 2 days ago

The Florida governor’s humiliating loss has a dark undertone: Most Republicans, and many independents, apparently have a craving for the unchecked lawless vengeance that Trump has promised if he wins a second term.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

Based on details that have emerged about Trump’s presidential agenda, the far-right Heritage Foundation plans for the next GOP president to have all the tools necessary to demolish multicultural democracy and establish a white, Christian ethnostate that imposes a gender apartheid not unlike the Taliban’s Afghanistan.