Watch

User menu

Search form

Why Keystone XL Cannot Pass the President's Climate Test

Why Keystone XL Cannot Pass the President's Climate Test
Wed, 1/22/2014 - by Tom Steyer

In the private sector, I made investment decisions looking at the economics of a project. When I look at the proposed Keystone XL pipeline, it is great deal…for the oil industry. And a vital one. It’s also a great deal for China and the foreign investors who stand to profit from increased production.

But it is a terrible deal for the American people, who will bear the environmental and economic risks of a spill without seeing any of the profits. This pipeline represents a long-term commitment, locking us in to a production cycle that will developing more of this dirty oil at a time when we should be looking for ways to tackle climate change head on.

Six months ago, President Obama drew his own line in the tar sands, making it clear that the Keystone XL pipeline would only be approved if “the project does not significantly exacerbate the problem of carbon pollution.”

Last month, I joined experts in the field of climate science to take an empirical approach to the question, “can Keystone pass the President’s climate test?”

The answer, we found, is no.

In my talk, I laid out how Keystone XL would unlock the Alberta tar sands, and all of the carbon that comes with it. The project would spur investment in the tar sands and enable the oil industry to ramp up production at an irreversible rate, with potentially devastating impacts on the global climate.

President Obama’s decision will send a signal to the whole world on whether our nation has the capacity, commitment and courage to be a global leader on climate change – before it's too late.

Tom Steyer is a San Francisco-based asset manager, philanthropist, environmentalist and funder helping to drive progressive climate policy in California.

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Sign Up

Article Tabs

Their tactics to force construction of data centers even against significant opposition from local communities have become increasingly forceful and hostile.

Whether Republicans want to be the party of Christianity or the party of worshipping false idols is a question they’ll have to seriously reckon with very soon, unless they want the American electorate to speak for them.

“Storytelling teaches not through instruction, but through imagination and example,” says the Sami artist Máret Ánne Sara. “These stories don’t provide direct answers, but rather the ethical tools to navigate and sustain the world.”

Republicans’ fate in the 2026 midterms is likely sealed. But they could be out of power for multiple subsequent election cycles if Democrats are smart.

In November, Indigenous protests in London included the launch of “Bringing It All Back Home,” confronting corporate power head-on.

Their tactics to force construction of data centers even against significant opposition from local communities have become increasingly forceful and hostile.

Whether Republicans want to be the party of Christianity or the party of worshipping false idols is a question they’ll have to seriously reckon with very soon, unless they want the American electorate to speak for them.

“Storytelling teaches not through instruction, but through imagination and example,” says the Sami artist Máret Ánne Sara. “These stories don’t provide direct answers, but rather the ethical tools to navigate and sustain the world.”

Republicans’ fate in the 2026 midterms is likely sealed. But they could be out of power for multiple subsequent election cycles if Democrats are smart.

In November, Indigenous protests in London included the launch of “Bringing It All Back Home,” confronting corporate power head-on.

Republicans’ fate in the 2026 midterms is likely sealed. But they could be out of power for multiple subsequent election cycles if Democrats are smart.

Posted 1 month 6 days ago

Whether Republicans want to be the party of Christianity or the party of worshipping false idols is a question they’ll have to seriously reckon with very soon, unless they want the American electorate to speak for them.

Posted 1 month 6 days ago

Their tactics to force construction of data centers even against significant opposition from local communities have become increasingly forceful and hostile.

Posted 6 days 15 hours ago

“Storytelling teaches not through instruction, but through imagination and example,” says the Sami artist Máret Ánne Sara. “These stories don’t provide direct answers, but rather the ethical tools to navigate and sustain the world.”

Posted 1 month 6 days ago