Read

User menu

Search form

The Real Costs of Uber: Putting Passenger Safety and Taxi Driver Livelihoods At Risk

The Real Costs of Uber: Putting Passenger Safety and Taxi Driver Livelihoods At Risk
Thu, 7/17/2014 - by Joseph Mayton

SAN FRANCISCO – In Europe last month, a barrage of protests erupted with the launch of the Uber app ride service as taxi drivers from London, Paris, Madrid and Milan demanded their governments intervene to ensure that all Uber drivers are held to the same safety and bureaucratic standards as taxi drivers.

Now, here in Uber's hometown, San Francisco, concerns continue to rise and a battle for the streets is heating up as more and more Uber drivers hit the roads while taxi drivers struggle in ever greater ways to make ends meet.

Backed by funders like Goldman Sachs and Google Ventures, the on-demand ride service company has exploded in popularity over the past year – though it is now beginning to discover in the Bay Area and across the globe that its popularity has come at a great, and not necessarily sustainable, cost.

Already, women have experienced numerous assaults by the company's unregulated drivers, while licensed taxi drivers continue to pay stiff fees even as their fares drop and their work hours increase in order to stay afloat.

“We are part of a growing community across the world that wants to be more into sharing. We are part of the shared economy,” one Uber official, who asked not to be named, recently told Occupy.com after the June protests against Uber erupted in London and elsewhere across Europe. At the moment, that argument is looking like a hard sell – though the official defended it as the heart of the company's mission.

“Uber is growing because many people around the world want and are demanding new ways of getting to their destination, and we’re doing it at a cheaper rate than the traditional means available,” the official said. Skirting questions relating to the slack requirements on Uber drivers – who aren't required to fulfill the same safety or bureaucratic requirements as regulated taxi drivers – he said it came down to the marketplace. “What we saw was a void of competition that would keep people happy and that is why Uber was created,” the official continued. “If there wasn’t a demand for what we are doing, we wouldn’t be as successful.”

Fairness and Safety On the Roads?

Leaked documents published on Valley Wag show that the company is bringing in over $20 million in weekly revenue – a huge sum, and taxi drivers are none too pleased about the fares going elsewhere. As a result, protests took off across the world, starting here in San Francisco where taxi drivers called on legislators to take immediate action.

According to Sharma, an Indian-American cab driver in San Francisco, Uber drivers can be “just anyone off the street and there are no guarantees” of safety. He referred to the New Year’s Eve death of a six-year-old girl by an Uber driver in San Francisco.

“Uber does not have to insure their drivers," he added. "Passengers can be assaulted and the company is not responsible. They are not forcing their drivers to properly train, relying on GPS for those drivers who don’t know the area, and most of the drivers are not doing this to survive and feed their family – they are just looking to make some extra cash on the side."

Taxi drivers face rounds of scrutiny before they can get behind the wheel, including drug tests and criminal background checks that register any record of prior sexual offenses. Uber, on the other hand, doesn’t go to these lengths; it considers itself a technology firm, not a taxi company, and the gray area makes it difficult for passengers to file complaints against Uber or even its drivers.

A number of women in the past year have reported being assaulted by Uber drivers. But unlike taxi services, where a passenger can clearly see phone numbers and license plate numbers of the driver in order to file a complaint, Uber has no such markings – which makes the company only marginally responsible for the behavior of its drivers.

One unnamed Uber driver in the Bay Area even boasted to Occupy.com that he “expected to pick up a girl every two weeks,” highlighting the potential threat of unvetted drivers.

“I don’t need this job really, I am here to make some extra cash and find some women," he said. "That’s why I am driving around.”

Beyond safety concerns for women, the app service is meanwhile forcing taxi drivers to work longer and longer hours – in the case of Sharma, for instance, increasing his daily time on the road from eight to between 10 and 12 hours.

"We pay a $110 fee every day to drive the taxi and now that people are using these new drivers, for whatever reason, it is hurting my ability to make a living,” he said.

Sharma said he is not against Uber being on the road per se, but wants to see more regulation forcing its private drivers to go through the same vetting and legalization process before they can get out on the road – creating a more level playing field.

“This is what matters. Because we have to go through a lot of training, pay fees, get insurance – this adds up," Sharma said, "and then when you have drivers who are just using their own car, not having any of the same requirements we have as taxi drivers, there is a problem. It is not just and fair. I think the government needs to step in."

3 WAYS TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT

ONE-TIME DONATION

Just use the simple form below to make a single direct donation.

DONATE NOW

MONTHLY DONATION

Be a sustaining sponsor. Give a reacurring monthly donation at any level.

GET SOME MERCH!

Now you can wear your support too! From T-Shirts to tote bags.

SHOP TODAY

Comments

No matter what people say am confident how uber is changing the way people travel. At the same time the employment opportunities it provides to the driver is huge. I have been driving Uber for past couple of months and yea I made more than what routine taxi job used to pay me. I really dont understand what is the fuzz about uber being putting driver at risk. If you want to drive with uber than drive or leave it. Its that simple. With services like <a href=http://uberestimate.org>uber estimator</a> one can now even know how much money the driver would make per ride.

A happy uber driver.

[url=http://uberestimate.org]Uber Estimator[/url]

Find out the cost of your Uber ride using http://uberestimate.org/

Sign Up

Article Tabs

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

The tragic shooting of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo is just the latest example of ICE having a fundamental disrespect for human life — further proving why the agency should be stripped of funding and shut down, and its rank-and-file agents and leadership prosecuted.

While the U.S., EU and their allies are enabling Rojava—the strongest force against Islamic State— to fall, it is vital for internationalists to continue to support this beacon of democracy and liberation.

June 23, 2026 may be remembered as the beginning of the end of the Democratic Party establishment.

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

We can still celebrate success while simultaneously putting a cap on net worth.

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

Much like the resistance to AI data centers, the opposition to Flock surveillance cameras has brought the left and the right together against billionaires who are trying to force America into becoming even more of a police state.

Much like the resistance to AI data centers, the opposition to Flock surveillance cameras has brought the left and the right together against billionaires who are trying to force America into becoming even more of a police state.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

The country’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, has promised a break from the politics of the last 40 years—realizing more broadly that Labour must stand up for the 99% against big business, or the party will become irrelevant.

Posted 1 month 3 weeks ago

We can still celebrate success while simultaneously putting a cap on net worth.

Posted 1 month 1 week ago

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

Posted 2 weeks 2 days ago

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.

Posted 2 weeks 5 days ago

The current wave of food recalls is a direct byproduct of President Donald Trump’s administration deliberately removing the safeguards put in place aimed at protecting American consumers more than a century ago.

From a pro-democratic perspective, civil society and new media organisations are surging in the aftermath of the Orban regime.